Circumcision of the Heart
Romans Chapter 2
Judge Not
Having just taken the Greeks to task in the previous chapter, Paul begins Chapter 2, in verses 1-4, by saying that the Jews have no right to judge. First, he said, the Jews were no better behaved than the Greeks. Considering the impressive catalog of immorality Paul attributed to the Greeks in 1:26-32, this must have had the Jews frothing at the mouth. Probably, they loudly objected, demanding to know how Paul dared to say they had behaved like these amoral Greeks.
I do not know what their actual behavior was, perhaps they were good people, but Jesus had already explained that the rules for keeping score were not what they had been thinking. The scribes and Pharisees brought Jesus a woman caught “in the very act” of adultery, and continually pestered Jesus, saying that the law required her to be stoned. Jesus, famously replied “He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her” and they all went away, one by one (John 8:4-11). What were there sins? Maybe they had already heard Jesus say: “You have heard that it was said, ‘Do not commit adultery.’ But I tell you that anyone who looks at a woman lustfully has already committed adultery with her in his heart.” (Matthew 5:27-28) Jesus told them that the commandments are not for accusing one another, but that they are about how we feel as well as act towards one another.
Paul goes on to say that only God’s judgment is righteous, and we, who are subject to his righteousness, have instead been shown kindness. If we do not extend kindness, tolerance, and patience to others, then Paul says we show contempt for the kindness God shows to us.
Doing Good
In verses 5-11, Paul continues with his theme of equality of Jew and Gentile, but along the way he touches on another subject that is worth close attention. Let us begin by noticing that the passage is filled with Old Testament terminology. Even the term “repent” in New Testament times (which I suppose extend to our day) has largely been replaced. In our day we have the great promise that “whosoever believeth” shall be saved, and so we have a general call to belief, instead of a call to repentance. Why then, does Paul call us to repentance, and to a life of good works?
We do have that great promise of salvation, and it can never fail, and can never be taken away from us. The same Christ though whom that great promise was made gave us very clear statements about the living of our lives. There are a handful of them, and they are all very similar.
Do to others as you would have them do to you. (Luke 6:31)
Jesus replied: “‘Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind.’ This is the first and greatest commandment. The second is like it: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’ All the Law and the Prophets hang on these two commandments.” (Matthew 22:37-40
A new command I give you: Love one another. As I have loved you, so you must love one another. (John 13:34).
So, Jesus had very definite ideas about how we are to live our lives. Is it a part of salvation, or a separate thing? We are saved by faith, but Paul and James want to know if faith can be separated from works. The question is an interesting bookend to Christ’s interpretation of the commandments. If I can break the command against murder, for example, by keeping hate in my heart, can I keep the commandment to love my neighbor only in my heart? If I see my neighbor sick, or in prison, or in poverty, can I simply feel love in my heart, where Jesus says the commandments must be kept, or is there something I must do? I need to know the answer, because, if it is the latter, there is quite a lot of something that needs to be done.
A Law unto Themselves
Before reading verses 12-16, we need to remind ourselves that Paul dictated his letters, and did so in the days before word processors, or even cheap pen and paper, so very little editing went on. As we have been noting, Paul has been switching back and forth between addressing the Jews and the Greeks (or gentiles) and at the same time developing a summary of the gospel. If you can imagine the scene as Paul paces back and forth before Tertius (we meet him in 16:22) getting more and more excited about his various trains of thought, but each one taking him further from his central thought. In these verses, it begins to break down, and either Paul or Tertius, or both, begin to have trouble keeping up.
It will help us to read it to note that verses 14 and 15 are an extended parenthetical remark. If we read 12, 13, and 15, we see that Paul is saying that law or no law, we will be judged by our behavior. Those who do what is right will be judged righteous, and those who do not will perish. How do we know what is right? That is where the parenthetical remark comes in. Paul says that the Jews have the law, so they have no excuse. But the gentiles, even without the law, know what is right. It is written on their hearts, Paul says.
After all, how mysterious is “love your neighbor as yourself”?
You Call Yourself a Jew?
In verses 17-24, Paul really lays into the Jews, because they should have been an example to all the other nations, a priestly nation of ambassadors for their God. Instead, they set themselves up as better than the other nations, and in the name of their God, proclaimed the other nations beneath contempt. One of the nice things about reading Paul, though, is that he is always talking about the law, or circumcision, or some problems in some little church somewhere, and never has anything to say about us.
There is a fancy word: “syncretization”. It means to bring together different ideas or philosophies. Paul spent so much of his effort syncretizing the Jewish religion and the Christian faith that we have to spend some effort syncretizing at least Paul’s terminology with ours. Paul talked about what it meant to be Jewish, about the importance of the law, and about circumcision all in a way that are foreign to modern Christians.
It is hard for us to identify with everything it meant to be Jewish, but it certainly meant to be the people of God. Paul asks them what they had accomplished with their special status as a people of faith: had they been a priestly nation, leading others to the Lord, or had they instead been a poor example, preaching their own importance, rather than the love of God. When we understand the words Paul was using, the message hits closer to home.
Circumcision of the Heart
In the final verses of the chapter, verses 25-29, Paul continues to talk about being a Jew, being circumcised, and keeping the law. In reading these verses, we have to keep in mind the previous verses where Paul has already established that it is not the hearing of the law, but the keeping of the law that matters, and that the gentiles know right from wrong by their very nature as creatures of God (a very different idea of human nature than we often assume).
In these passages, Paul addresses another Jewish idea: that the gentiles cannot have a relationship with God simply because they are gentiles. After all, God chose the Jews and God gave them circumcision as the special mark of his covenant. We can almost hear them say “We do not judge the gentiles, God does.” Again, it is so good that Paul is talking to some thick-headed Jews from centuries ago, and not to us.
But Paul says that what God really wants is a circumcised heart. The Jews knew all about circumcision. They had Mohels who were trained, and they knew all the rituals. But how do you circumcise a heart? And then Paul goes further with a little pun that is lost in our translation. He says of a man with a circumcised heart that his “praise is not from men, but of God.” This is a strange statement, on the face of it. There are places in the Bible where God has positive things to say about individuals, but not praise, exactly. But, here is the pun. The word “Jew” is derived from the word “Judah”, which itself means “praised”. Paul says that those who are circumcised in heart are made “Jews” by God.
The idea of circumcised hearts is not Paul’s, by the way; it is the Lord’s himself. He says, for example, in Deuteronomy 30:6 that he will circumcise our hearts that we may love him with all our hearts and all our souls, and live.
Paul, on good Biblical basis, says that we cannot judge others – not on their actions, race, or creed. But we do know right from wrong, and we must repent of our evil ways. To repent means to change and Paul says that this change does come from a statement of faith, or from baptism, or from dressing up and going to church on Sunday, or from any other external act. Paul says it requires inward change. He calls it “circumcision of the heart”. This change cannot be performed by any ritual or tested against any code or human standard. It is performed by the grace of God and tested by his love.